GLENDALE, Calif. — A proposal to dramatically increase water rates brought a packed crowd to Glendale City Hall on Nov. 10, with dozens more seated in an overflow room as residents questioned the city’s financial decisions, infrastructure spending and handling of public outreach.
At the center of the controversy is Glendale Water & Power’s proposal to increase water-rate revenue by 53% in the first year, followed by additional annual increases of 11%, 10%, 10% and 7% through 2031.
Compounded, the increases would raise the utility’s annual rate revenue by approximately 120% over five years. The percentages represent increases in overall rate revenue, not necessarily the amount individual customers would see on their bills.
GWP says the increases are necessary to repair aging infrastructure, cover rising operating costs and fund capital improvements.
But after more than five hours of public testimony, questions and deliberations, the discussion raised a larger issue: How did Glendale reach a point where the utility says it needs such a substantial increase — and why does it have to happen now?
The proposal was originally scheduled for consideration Nov. 3, but the City Council voted to keep the public hearing open and continue the matter to Nov. 10.
Councilmembers again declined to make a final decision, voting unanimously to leave the hearing open for another week.
The decision gives opponents additional time to submit formal written protests while councilmembers examine legal concerns, meet with stakeholders and consider alternatives to the proposed increases.
Residents question the city’s outreach
One of the most consistent complaints during the hearing involved communication.
Several Glendale residents told councilmembers they had spent days walking neighborhoods, knocking on doors and explaining the proposal to people who said they knew nothing about the increases.
Glendale resident Kirsten described the response she received while canvassing.
“Not one person that I came in contact with had ever even heard about these increases until I showed them,” she said.
Another resident described distributing approximately 300 notices and encountering an elderly woman who became emotional after learning about the proposed increases.
Glendale resident Karen questioned the way the city had handled the process.
“It feels like what you’re proposing and how you went about doing it is very underhanded and very suspect,” she told councilmembers.
Others raised concerns about transparency.
“Mr. Mellon uses words like total transparency, tough decisions. I ask you, where is the integrity part?” asked Glendale resident Tigran.
GWP defended its outreach, saying it mailed the required Proposition 218 notices, held community meetings and worked with local organizations to distribute information.
But an exchange during council deliberations highlighted a distinction between sending notices and ensuring residents received them.
“Every customer, commercial, industrial, residential, did receive a Prop 218 notification,” said city manager Roubik Golanian.
Mayor Ardy Kassakhian challenged that characterization.
“I think there’s an issue with perhaps how we word this because saying that they received it, what is probably most accurate is saying it was sent, not whether someone received it.”
The city is required to mail notices as part of the Proposition 218 process. Whether those efforts adequately informed residents remained a point of contention throughout the hearing.
Why now? The $40 million bond proposal
While GWP has emphasized the need to repair aging water infrastructure, the hearing revealed another factor driving the timing of the proposed increases.
The utility plans to issue $40 million in bonds to help finance capital improvements.
According to GWP’s finance representative, the utility needs additional rate revenue to meet financial requirements associated with the proposed borrowing.
GWP said delaying the rate increase until March could cause its projected debt-service coverage ratio to fall from the required 1.10 to approximately 0.88.
“If we have below that 1.10, we will not be able to secure the bonds,” the finance representative told councilmembers.
Without the anticipated financing, GWP said it could be forced to draw more heavily on reserves, delay projects or reconsider spending.
The explanation prompted questions about whether the utility’s financing schedule was contributing to the urgency of the proposed increases.
“You guys can’t even postpone this till March because of the bonds. And that’s a result of mismanagement,” said Glendale resident Mary.
The exchange raised a question that would become central to council deliberations: Was the timing driven solely by the condition of Glendale’s water system, or also by financial commitments the city had already made?
A contract already in place
Among those commitments is GWP’s Advanced Metering Infrastructure project, which will replace the city’s water meters.
During the hearing, GWP confirmed that the meter replacement contract is active and that the city is contractually obligated to carry out the work.
The utility identified the overall project budget as approximately $26 million, including $11 million accounted for through existing funds and approximately $15.3 million included in the proposed financial plan.
When councilmembers questioned what would happen if the rate increase were delayed, staff acknowledged that continuing the project on its current schedule without additional revenue could create financial difficulties.
“Because we’ve committed to the AMI project, and if we don’t put a pause on that project, we will be closing in the negative, and we are contractually obligated to do the work that’s in the contract,” a GWP representative said.
Staff said pausing the project was possible but cautioned that doing so was not necessarily practical.
The explanation prompted Councilmember Vartan Gharpetian to question why the city had entered into the agreement without first securing the money needed to complete the work.
“But if we don’t have the money, how can we sign a contract? Maybe someone can answer that for me. I don’t understand that,” Gharpetian said.
Inclusive Voices Media’s investigation revealed that the council — including Gharapetian — unanimously voted to approve that contract in April.
The exchange raised questions about the city’s financial planning and the information presented to councilmembers when the contract was approved.
It also highlighted the pressure created by an existing contractual commitment as the city considers a rate increase that has not yet been authorized.
The hearing did not establish the specific financial penalties, if any, that would result from pausing or modifying the contract.
Are the projects ready?
Gharpetian also questioned whether GWP needed to secure the entire $40 million in bond financing on its proposed schedule.
“I know that we are anxious to get that $40 million bond, but we don’t have the projects that are ready for those bonds,” he said.
GWP explained that the first year of its capital improvement program would focus primarily on meter replacement, while staff prepared projects scheduled for subsequent years.
Those preparations would include planning, design, bidding and contract approvals.
According to staff, the proposed borrowing would support capital projects over approximately the first two and a half years of the program.
The discussion raised questions about whether a different borrowing schedule or project timeline could reduce the immediate financial pressure without jeopardizing necessary infrastructure improvements.
Years of infrastructure spending questioned
GWP’s proposed five-year financial plan includes approximately $474 million in total projected water-system expenditures.
That includes approximately $145 million for imported water, more than $113 million in operating expenses and $100 million for capital improvements.
The $474 million represents total projected expenditures, not the amount of new borrowing or the cost of infrastructure improvements alone.
The proposed capital improvement program would substantially increase infrastructure spending compared with recent years.
But residents questioned why more had not been invested earlier.
Glendale resident Philip pointed to the utility’s historical spending and questioned whether GWP could deliver on its proposed construction schedule.
“Actual capital spending fell to $1.7 million in 2024. Now it promises $20 million a year, four times its recent pace, plus $40 million in bonds,” he said.
“If pipe spending dropped below $2 million a year while the pipes were aging, why should we believe the next five years will be different?”
He called for a more detailed capital improvement plan and greater accountability for how the proposed revenue would be spent.
Other residents questioned whether the increases could be phased in more gradually.
“Households cannot reasonably be budgeted for a rate increase of this magnitude with such little notice,” said Joseph, who spoke on behalf of a rental housing organization.
He urged councilmembers to spread the increases more evenly over the five-year period.
Glendale resident Teres, a former city employee, warned that the proposal could further strain households already struggling with the cost of living.
“People are already struggling with the increased cost of living while wages have remained stagnant, and this will just put them over the edge,” she said.
Councilmembers acknowledge past decisions
During deliberations, councilmembers acknowledged that Glendale’s infrastructure problems had developed over years.
One councilmember described the absence of a comprehensive water infrastructure master plan as “total bonkers.”
The councilmember also criticized previous decisions to postpone difficult financial choices.
“We have a serious issue with previous council that they don’t want to raise rates. They don’t address these issues because they didn’t want to be the bad guys that have left us in this position.”
Mayor Ardy Kassakhian made a similar argument, saying previous councils’ efforts to avoid placing additional financial burdens on residents had contributed to the current situation.
“Part of why we’re here today is because we’ve had these, and the previous councils have been very empathetic, and I understand that, but that empathy has gotten us to where we are today,” Kassakhian said.
Kassakhian also acknowledged the financial pressure residents are facing, sharing examples of substantial increases in his own household’s utility bills.
He argued that postponing necessary infrastructure investments could lead to even greater costs in the future.
Legal objections raise additional questions
The hearing also brought objections from major commercial stakeholders, including Forest Lawn, the Americana at Brand and Glendale Galleria.
Correspondence from the Americana questioned whether GWP’s cost-of-service analysis complied with Proposition 218, which governs certain property-related fees and charges in California.
The correspondence challenged aspects of the utility’s cost allocations, the scale of its capital improvement program and assumptions in its financial plan.
The city attorney defended the analysis, saying it had undergone legal review.
“We believe our COSA complies with Prop 218,” the attorney told councilmembers, referring to the cost-of-service analysis.
Councilmembers Elen Asatryan expressed concern about proceeding without further examining the objections and speaking directly with stakeholders.
Council keeps hearing open
Following hours of testimony and debate, the City Council voted 5-0 to leave the public hearing open and continue the matter to Nov. 17.
The decision allows opponents additional time to submit formal written protests under Proposition 218.
City officials reported receiving more than 4,300 valid protests, compared with a threshold of approximately 22,000 needed to block the proposal through the majority-protest process.
Councilmembers will also use the additional week to seek clarification about legal objections and give GWP staff time to evaluate possible changes to the rate structure.
The proposed increases have not been approved.
For now, the debate remains unresolved.
GWP maintains that significant investment is necessary to protect the reliability of Glendale’s water system.
But the hearing exposed questions about decisions that preceded the proposed increases — including years of infrastructure spending, the timing of a major meter replacement contract, the need for $40 million in borrowing and whether the public was adequately informed.
The central question is no longer simply whether Glendale needs to invest in its water system.
It is whether the city has demonstrated that its proposed financing plan, and the financial burden it places on residents, is the most responsible way to pay for that investment.
Inclusive Voices Media will continue following the proposed rate increases and the City Council’s deliberations.










