GLENDALE, Calif. — Glendale City Councilmember Dan Brotman says the city may have moved too quickly when it approved a roughly $26 million water meter replacement contract, acknowledging that the decision left councilmembers with fewer options as they considered substantial increases to residents’ water rates.
In a candid interview with Inclusive Voices Media on Nov. 11, Brotman expressed frustration over the timing of the contract, which the City Council unanimously approved in April, months before Glendale Water & Power publicly presented its completed Cost of Service Analysis.
“It’s a good question. I think we got ahead of ourselves, and I’m frustrated,” Brotman said when asked why the council approved the agreement before all of its funding was secured.
The contract covers the replacement of Glendale’s Advanced Metering Infrastructure, or AMI, a system used to collect water meter readings remotely and provide customers with information about their water consumption.
GWP says the existing technology is aging and increasingly unreliable, making replacement necessary.
But the project’s financing has become a point of contention as the utility seeks approval for significant water rate increases.
‘Our back’s against the wall’
During the interview, Brotman said the AMI project was presented to councilmembers as a necessary investment, but he believes they did not fully appreciate how approving the contract would affect the timetable for completing the city’s rate study.
“I don’t think if you ask any of the five of us, did any of us understand that this was going to lock us in to a very short time frame to get a COSA done,” Brotman said, referring to the Cost of Service Analysis.
The COSA determines how much revenue GWP needs to operate its water system, fund infrastructure improvements and meet financial obligations. It also establishes how those costs would be allocated among customers.
Brotman said the council should have delayed approval of the AMI contract until it had a clearer understanding of the financial consequences.
“We should have held that,” he said. “We could have held that. And we should have.”
He acknowledged that the city might ultimately have approved the same project and financing plan.
“But it would have at least given council a little more optionality, because now I feel like our back’s against the wall,” Brotman said.
Brotman’s comments followed a Nov. 10 City Council hearing during which GWP officials warned that postponing the proposed rate increases could create financial difficulties because the AMI contract was already in effect.
Staff said continuing the project’s scheduled expenditures without sufficient revenue could cause the water fund to end the fiscal year with a negative balance.
The utility also identified separate financial pressures associated with a proposed $40 million bond issuance intended to support multiple capital improvement projects.
What councilmembers were told in April
The City Council approved the AMI contract April 28.
During that meeting, councilmembers questioned GWP about the project’s cost and its potential impact on water rates.
GWP Assistant General Manager Chisum Obegolu told councilmembers that approximately $12 million was already budgeted and that the remaining $14 million would be incorporated into the upcoming COSA.
Obegolu characterized the project’s impact as relatively small compared with the utility’s broader financial requirements.
When pressed for a specific estimate of how much the project would increase customer rates, however, staff acknowledged that the cost-of-service analysis had not yet been completed.
GWP General Manager Scott Mellon also acknowledged during the April discussion that infrastructure costs would ultimately be reflected in water rates and would likely contribute to higher charges.
The council unanimously approved the agreement.
The April record therefore shows that councilmembers were informed of a potential rate impact, although the discussion did not establish a specific household rate increase attributable to the AMI project.
Brotman’s criticism centers on the financial consequences of approving the contract before the rate study was finalized.
“I don’t think any of us put it all together at the time,” he said during the interview.
He also acknowledged that the council, not just utility staff, bears responsibility for the decision.
“Ultimately, we’re accountable, right, to the public,” Brotman said.
Why GWP wants to borrow $40 million
The interview also addressed GWP’s proposed $40 million bond issuance, which has generated questions among residents about why the utility wants to borrow the entire amount rather than issue bonds in smaller increments.
Brotman said he understood the decision to involve the costs associated with issuing municipal debt.
He explained that issuing two smaller bonds could mean paying certain financing, legal and administrative costs twice.
“Doing it together saves money,” Brotman said.
However, the proposed $40 million bond and the approximately $26 million AMI contract are separate components of GWP’s broader financial plan.
The bond proposal is intended to help finance multiple water infrastructure projects over several years. It should not be interpreted as a $40 million payment for the AMI system.
GWP has also identified existing funds and anticipated future rate revenue as part of its AMI financing plan.
During the Nov. 10 hearing, staff described approximately $11 million in existing funds for the project and another $15.3 million incorporated into the COSA.
Those figures differ somewhat from the approximate $12 million and $14 million breakdown presented in April.
The difference has not been fully reconciled in the records reviewed by Inclusive Voices Media.
Brotman defends the need for infrastructure investment
Despite his criticism of the contract approval process, Brotman strongly defended the need to invest in Glendale’s water infrastructure.
He said the city’s current financial challenges are partly the result of previous decisions to hold down rates rather than invest adequately in maintenance and replacement.
“The reality is we have been paying too little for too long for our water,” Brotman said.
He argued that Glendale is confronting a problem shared by many cities: Aging infrastructure that requires increasingly expensive repairs and replacement.
According to Brotman, postponing investments may avoid immediate increases but can create larger costs for future residents.
“We can choose not to raise rates, and then we are choosing to let our system deteriorate and to pay more later because we’re going to have water main breaks,” he said.
Brotman also praised GWP for undertaking a comprehensive Water Master Plan to identify the city’s long-term infrastructure needs.
The plan identifies approximately $917 million in recommended capital improvements over 20 years.
GWP’s proposed five-year financial program would fund approximately $100 million in capital improvements, prioritizing projects the utility considers most urgent.
Brotman’s assessment that Glendale’s water rates have historically been too low reflects his policy position. Whether past rates were sufficient to meet infrastructure needs requires examining historical rate decisions, utility finances and investment levels.
What the proposed increases mean for residents
GWP’s proposal calls for a 53% increase in total water rate revenue in the first year, followed by annual increases of 11%, 10%, 10% and 7%.
Compounded, the proposal would increase annual water rate revenue by approximately 120% over five years.
Those percentages represent systemwide revenue increases, not identical increases on every household’s bill.
Individual customer impacts would vary based on water consumption, meter size and elevation zone.
During the interview, Harapetian asked Brotman how the city could make increases of that magnitude more acceptable to residents already struggling with the cost of living.
Brotman described the decision as a trade-off between paying for infrastructure improvements now and facing potentially greater costs later.
“It’s either pay now or pay later,” he said.
He argued that rejecting the proposed increases would not eliminate the underlying infrastructure needs.
But the choices available to the council are not necessarily limited to approving the proposal exactly as presented or abandoning infrastructure investment altogether. Different project schedules, financing arrangements and rate structures could potentially be considered, subject to legal, financial and operational constraints.
Brotman acknowledged that reconsidering the proposal could create delays and additional costs.
Could the city delay or revise the increases?
When asked whether the city could compromise on the proposed rate increases, Brotman said he believed the council’s options had become severely limited.
“We have to do these rate increases now because of all the things we talked about before,” he said, citing reserve levels and the time required to issue new Proposition 218 notices.
Under California’s Proposition 218, property-related water rate increases generally require advance notice and an opportunity for affected property owners or customers to submit written protests.
If a majority of the affected parcels submit valid protests, the agency cannot impose the proposed increase through that proceeding.
The law does not, however, automatically require a city to approve a particular rate proposal merely because it has completed the notice process.
The council can consider other legally permissible options, although material changes to the proposed rates may require additional analysis and a new notice process.
Brotman said that if the proposed increases were blocked, the city would have to develop another financial plan.
He suggested GWP might need to pause the AMI contract, reconsider its financing or explore other temporary funding arrangements.
“There would be penalties to do that. I don’t know,” he said, acknowledging that utility staff would need to determine the actual costs.
The interview did not establish whether the AMI agreement contains specific suspension penalties or what a temporary pause would cost.
Brotman also raised the possibility of using General Fund resources or loans, while acknowledging that such options would involve complicated legal and financial questions.
Those were potential alternatives he discussed, not approved or verified funding arrangements.
Responding to public criticism
Brotman also addressed claims circulating in the community about transfers from GWP to the city’s General Fund and whether the proposed water rate increases are connected to future development.
He rejected suggestions that the water rate proposal was intended to support General Fund transfers or anticipated development.
However, two different financial issues must be distinguished.
GWP has stated that water utility revenue is not transferred to the General Fund.
Glendale also imposes a separate utility users tax on applicable water charges, with that tax revenue going directly to the General Fund. Higher water rates can therefore generate additional tax revenue without constituting a transfer from the water utility.
As for development, Brotman argued that theoretical housing capacity calculations in Glendale’s planning documents should not be treated as predictions of how much housing will actually be built.
Accountability and the decisions ahead
Throughout the interview, Brotman returned to two positions: Glendale needs to invest in its aging water system, and the council should have handled the AMI approval process differently.
He said the timing of the contract had left councilmembers feeling pressured to approve a particular financial plan.
“I think it could have been handled better,” Brotman said.
But he rejected the suggestion that delaying the AMI contract would necessarily have eliminated the need for higher rates.
“This is more about process than about results,” he said.
That distinction is central to the continuing debate.
The Water Master Plan identifies substantial infrastructure needs, and GWP says higher revenue is necessary to address them.
At the same time, the council’s decision to approve the AMI contract before the COSA was completed has raised questions about financial planning, oversight and the amount of flexibility available to elected officials and residents.
Brotman said the council ultimately must answer for those decisions.
“Ultimately, we’re accountable, right, to the public,” he said.
Inclusive Voices Media is continuing its investigation into Glendale’s proposed water rate increases, the AMI contract and the financial decisions that shaped the city’s current proposal.










