GLENDALE, Calif. — When Glendale City Councilmember Dan Brotman acknowledged in an exclusive interview with Inclusive Voices Media that the city may have moved too quickly in approving a roughly $26 million water meter replacement contract, his comments raised a question: What exactly had councilmembers been told before voting to approve the project?
“I think we got ahead of ourselves, and I’m frustrated,” Brotman said during the Nov. 11 interview.
His admission prompted Inclusive Voices Media to examine the public record, including City Council meeting videos, transcripts, staff presentations and documents surrounding the April 28 contract approval and subsequent discussions about proposed water rate increases.
The investigation found that councilmembers repeatedly questioned Glendale Water & Power about the project’s financial impact before approving the contract.
GWP officials described that impact as “insignificant” and “very negligible” compared with the utility’s broader financial requirements. But when pressed for a specific estimate of how much the project would increase water rates, staff acknowledged that the financial analysis needed to calculate the impact had not yet been completed.
Six months later, during a Nov. 10 hearing on proposed water rate increases, GWP warned that the contract was already in effect and that continuing the project without anticipated rate revenue could create financial difficulties.
The findings raise questions about the information available to councilmembers when they approved the agreement, the assumptions underlying GWP’s financial assurances and whether the decision reduced the city’s flexibility before residents had an opportunity to weigh in on proposed rate increases.
Inclusive Voices Media submitted written questions to GWP on Nov. 14 seeking clarification about the contract and its financing. As of publication on Nov. 17, before the City Council’s scheduled meeting, the utility had not responded.
A $26 million decision
On April 28, the Glendale City Council considered a contract to replace the city’s Advanced Metering Infrastructure, commonly known as AMI.
The system allows water meters to transmit usage information remotely, reducing the need for manual meter readings and providing customers with more timely information about water consumption.
GWP said the existing technology was aging, experiencing failures and no longer supported by its manufacturer.
According to the utility, approximately 40% of Glendale’s 36,000 water meter communication endpoints were no longer transmitting data.
The failures required employees to manually read thousands of meters and limited some customers’ ability to monitor their water use remotely.
GWP presented the replacement as a necessary investment to modernize the system and improve reliability.
But councilmembers wanted to know how the city would pay for it — and what the project would mean for residents’ water bills.
Councilmembers repeatedly questioned the financial impact
During the April 28 meeting, Brotman questioned GWP Assistant General Manager Chisom Obegolu about the project’s cost.
“Maybe you could walk through that and kind of how you see this potentially impacting water rates or not impacting water rates?” Brotman asked. “Because you said it was a real — it was sticker shock when you look at it.”
Obegolu explained that approximately $12 million of the roughly $26 million project was already budgeted.
The remaining $14 million, he said, would be incorporated into the utility’s upcoming Cost of Service Analysis, or COSA.
The COSA is the financial study used to determine how much revenue GWP needs to operate its water system, fund infrastructure improvements and meet financial obligations. It also establishes how those costs are allocated among customers.
But the study had not yet been completed.
Despite that, Obegolu characterized the project’s financial impact as relatively small.
“Twelve million out of the 26 million is already budgeted, and so the remaining 14 million or so will be part of the next Cost of Service Analysis,” Obegolu told councilmembers.
He continued, saying the project would not have “a significant impact on the actual Cost of Service Analysis when you take into account everything else we’re doing.”
Brotman pressed for clarification.
“When you say will not have a significant impact, what is that?” he asked. “Can you be a little more specific about that?”
Obegolu explained that the utility’s broader financial program involved tens of millions of dollars in annual operating and capital expenses.
“And so you can see how that is insignificant when you take into account the grand scheme of that 60, 70 million dollar price tag,” he said.
The explanation placed the AMI expenditure in the context of GWP’s overall financial requirements.
But it did not establish how much the project would add to an individual customer’s water bill.
And Brotman was not the only councilmember asking.
‘It’s hard to tell now’
Later in the meeting, Councilmember Vartan Gharpetian raised the issue again.
“As far as the COSA goes, that 12 or 14 million dollars over three years, what do you think the impact will be?” Gharpetian asked. “The cost increase will be approximately?”
This time, Obegolu acknowledged that GWP could not yet provide a specific estimate.
“It’s hard to tell now, councilmember, without having done the analysis for the cost of service,” he said.
He then offered another assurance.
“For this specific project, the 14 million dollars over the three-year period would be very negligible in comparison to what we’re expecting,” Obegolu said. “We have bigger issues, if you will, that we would need to worry about as part of the COSA.”
GWP was describing the project’s cost as relatively small compared with its broader financial needs. It was not presenting a completed calculation showing that the AMI project would have a negligible impact on individual customer bills.
Nevertheless, councilmembers were being asked to approve the contract before the analysis needed to quantify that impact was available.
Gharpetian continued questioning the potential burden on ratepayers.
Using the approximate total project cost and number of meters, he estimated that the investment represented nearly $800 per meter.
“That’s why I think the COSA is important to understand how is it going to impact the rates,” he said.
He also expressed concern that the project could contribute to substantial future increases.
“I don’t want this to be another reason to increase the rates, really, you know, tremendously because we had this big investment in there,” Gharpetian said.
Dividing the contract cost by the number of meters does not establish what each customer would actually pay. Water rates are calculated using a broader financial model that considers operating expenses, capital investment, customer classifications and other factors.
But Gharpetian’s questions underscored the council’s concern about the project’s ultimate cost to residents.
Watch April 28th City Council Meeting.
GWP acknowledged rates would increase
After being pressed about the cost, GWP General Manager Scott Mellon finall acknowledged that the costs of infrastructure improvements would ultimately be reflected in customer rates.
“It will end up being in rates, and it most likely will be a higher rate,” Mellon told councilmembers.
What the exchanges reviewed by Inclusive Voices Media did not establish was the specific increase attributable to the AMI project or how approving the contract before completing the COSA might affect the city’s financial timetable.
The distinction between those two issues would become increasingly important months later.
Despite the unanswered questions about the project’s precise rate impact, the City Council unanimously approved the contract.
Six months later, a different financial warning
By November 10, the council was confronting a much larger financial decision.
GWP was seeking approval for a proposed water rate structure that would increase total annual water rate revenue by 53% in the first year, followed by additional increases of 11%, 10%, 10% and 7% over the next four years.
Those percentages represent increases in the utility’s total water rate revenue, not identical percentage increases for every customer’s bill.
The proposed increases were intended to support a broad range of expenses, including water purchases, operations, maintenance, aging infrastructure and capital improvements.
The AMI project was one component of that financial plan, not the sole reason for the proposed increases.
GWP also proposed issuing approximately $40 million in bonds to help finance multiple capital improvement projects.
But during the Nov. 10 council hearing, the already-approved AMI contract emerged as a source of financial pressure.
As councilmembers considered whether to delay action on the proposed rates, GWP staff warned that continuing the project without the anticipated revenue could leave the utility in a negative financial position.
“Because we’ve committed to the AMI project, and if we don’t put a pause on that project, we will be closing in the negative, and we are contractually obligated to do the work that’s in the contract,” a GWP representative told councilmembers.
Staff further explained that the contract was active and that continuing the scheduled meter replacements and expenditures without sufficient revenue would create financial difficulties.
The November warning presented a different dimension of the project’s financial impact.
In April, GWP had described the expenditure as relatively insignificant within its broader financial program.
By November, the utility was identifying the active contract as one factor limiting its ability to delay the proposed rate increases without financial consequences.
Watch November 10th City Council Meeting.
‘If we don’t have the money, how can we sign a contract?’
During the November 10 hearing, Gharpetian again questioned the financial implications of the agreement.
“But if we don’t have the money, how can we sign a contract?” he asked.
Approving a multiyear contract before collecting every dollar needed to pay for it is not inherently improper.
Government agencies frequently enter into agreements supported by future budgets, projected revenue or planned financing.
The central question is whether the agency has a credible funding plan and whether decision-makers understand the financial obligations and risks associated with that plan.
In April, GWP described approximately $12 million as already budgeted, with the remaining $14 million to be incorporated into the COSA.
By November, staff described approximately $11 million in existing water funds and another $15.3 million included in the rate study.
The figures are approximate and may reflect differences in budgeting, accounting or the timing of expenditures.
The records reviewed by Inclusive Voices Media do not establish that money disappeared or that the project’s cost increased by the difference between those figures. It confirms that the $15.3 million of the contract was expected to be supported by future rate revenue that had not yet been proposed or approved.
Could Glendale have delayed the project?
The November hearing also raised questions about whether the city could pause the AMI replacement while reconsidering its financing options.
GWP confirmed that the contract remained active and that continuing the installation schedule would require additional expenditures.
But the exchanges reviewed by Inclusive Voices Media did not establish the specific financial consequences of suspending or extending the agreement.
Would pausing the project trigger contractual penalties? Could the replacement schedule be extended? Could payments be spread over a longer period? What additional costs, if any, would the city incur by delaying the work?
Those details are necessary to evaluate how much flexibility the city actually retained after approving the contract.
They are also important when considering GWP’s broader financial warning.
The proposed $40 million bond issuance was intended to support multiple infrastructure projects and should not be confused with the AMI contract itself.
Likewise, the utility’s financial concerns extended beyond the meter replacement project.
Brotman’s admission prompts a closer examination
The questions surrounding the contract gained new significance following Inclusive Voices Media’s November 11 interview with Brotman.
Asked why the city approved the agreement before securing all the money needed to pay for it, Brotman acknowledged frustration with the decision-making process.
“It’s a good question. I think we got ahead of ourselves, and I’m frustrated,” he said.
Brotman explained that the project had been presented to councilmembers as a necessary investment.
But he said he did not believe they fully understood how approving it would affect the timeline for completing the COSA.
“I don’t think if you ask any of the five of us, did any of us understand that this was going to lock us in to a very short time frame to get a COSA done,” Brotman said.
His statement reflects his assessment of the council’s understanding. Inclusive Voices Media has not independently established that all five councilmembers shared that view.
Brotman said the council should have waited before approving the agreement.
“We should have held that,” he said. “We could have held that. And we should have.”
He acknowledged that the city might ultimately have approved the same project.
But delaying the decision, he said, could have preserved more flexibility.
“It would have at least given council a little more optionality, because now I feel like our back’s against the wall,” Brotman said.
Brotman also expressed frustration that the council was confronting the possibility of revisiting the COSA or delaying other financial decisions if it did not approve the proposed rate increases on the anticipated schedule.
“I think it could have been handled better,” he said.
Who is accountable?
During the interview, Brotman was asked whether responsibility rested with GWP staff or the councilmembers who approved the contract.
He acknowledged that the council had voted for the agreement.
“Ultimately, we’re accountable, right, to the public,” he said.
Brotman nevertheless defended the underlying need to replace aging infrastructure and invest in Glendale’s water system.
He argued that the city had deferred infrastructure investment for too long and that residents would eventually have to pay for necessary improvements.
He also said he believed the AMI project might have been approved even if the council had waited for additional financial information.
“This is more about process than about results,” Brotman said.
That distinction is central to the findings of Inclusive Voices Media’s review.
The available records do not establish that the AMI replacement was unnecessary, that the contract was unlawful or that GWP deliberately misled the council.
They do establish that councilmembers repeatedly sought clarification about the project’s financial impact before voting.
They also show that GWP characterized the impact as relatively insignificant while acknowledging that the study needed to quantify the rate effect had not yet been completed.
Months later, the utility warned that the contract was already binding and that continuing the project without anticipated revenue could create financial difficulties.
Brotman’s subsequent acknowledgment that the council should have waited adds another dimension to those findings.
GWP has not responded to written questions
As part of its investigation, Inclusive Voices Media submitted written questions to Glendale Water & Power on November 14.
The questions sought clarification about the AMI contract, its financing and the financial information presented to councilmembers before the agreement was approved.
As of publication on November 17, before the City Council’s scheduled meeting, GWP had not responded.
This report is part of Inclusive Voices Media’s continuing investigation into Glendale Water & Power’s proposed water rate increases, infrastructure planning and financial decisions.










